Showing posts with label Linearity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Linearity. Show all posts

Friday, January 29, 2010

Linearity vs. Spoilability: Part 1

In the last post, I talked a bit about why linearity and replayability are not well-correlated. Since I wrote that, I've been rethinking the whole notion of linearity in games, and concluded that it's not very useful. Much more useful in my opinion is the notion of 'spoilability', which I came up with last week.

My original intention was just to summarize my whole argument in one post, since it's fairly easy to explain. But I got a little sidetracked after getting part of it done a few days ago. So it's become a series. Here's part 1:

1. Linearity isn't a very useful concept.

This shouldn't come as a surprise, since I think the use of the word 'linear' in game reviews and criticism has dropped quite a bit over the past few years. Despite this, I think there's still a perception that nonlinearity is important, because it's the key characteristic that differentiates games as a form of storytelling from movies or books. And in an obvious sense, that's true. After all, those forms generally have a beginning, an end, and one conventional means by which to pass from the former to the latter. But what does it mean to call a game linear?

Usually, we use the term when we find a game too restrictive in one way or another. Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time is a good example. The main character has a wide range of fun acrobatic moves, yet in each room there's usually only one path that will not lead him to his death. This makes PoP more of a puzzle game than some players would have liked. So when we call the game 'too linear', we might be referring to this fact. Or we might be referring to the game's overarching narrative. After all, the game never gives us any choice in releasing the Sands of Time and causing all hell to break loose; I believe that takes place in a cutscene.

So we might differentiate between story-linearity and game-linearity. Still, there is no easy way to quantify these concepts, even in the most clear-cut examples. For instance, Knights of the Old Republic constantly offers you dialogue options that directly affect various character stats. Yet like many RPGs, there are only two viable paths for your character: the transcendent, inscrutable light Jedi or the greedy, asshole dark Jedi. As soon as you decide who you want to be, it's painfully obvious (except in interesting ambiguous cases which are far too rare) which lines to select in every single dialogue tree. This makes the game all too linear and even boring, which is the main reason I've never finished it.

Lots of games offer choices, but some choices aren't really choices at all. Some choices are explicit, and some, like Silent Hill 2's, aren't. There are games like Morrowind, where the main narrative can be avoided, but never really diverges once you decide to continue with it. What about free-form games like Civilization? Some would say they are completely non-linear given the range of possibilities. However, in narrative terms, Civ is really quite simple. You start with a society, it grows, and then either it dies or everyone else's does.

Again, I think a lot of game writers have figured out that 'linear' is an outdated term. But here's my idea, which DOES get at the real issue that people usually refer to when they use that word:

NEXT TIME: Spoilability!

Wednesday, January 27, 2010

A Straight Line of a Different Kind

Contra III is a 30 minute game that has lasted me over a month. The game has 6 levels, and none of them will take a skilled gamer more than a few minutes. But that's an easy enough thing to say. Yesterday I was overjoyed when I made it to the fifth level for the first time.

So why have I stuck with it for so long? It's true that I am a more patient gamer than ever before. I avoid using the word 'hardcore', since I respect gamers of all types, but it's true that patience and diligence count for something with this type of game. Ten years ago, I dedicated myself to adventure games because I was sick of game overs, but now I can't get enough of them.

The real reason is that Contra III is very fair. Like the Castlevania series, it's very well-crafted. I die often, but each time I know where I went wrong and how to do better next time. Unlike the Castlevania series, it's also a great adrenaline rush no matter how many times I play it.


Like most classic platformers and run'n'guns, Contra III is as linear as a game could possibly be, for good reason. Each difficult boss such as the one above (which was the hardest for me so far) has one crucial weakness: it's forced to act the same way every single time. If it didn't, I'd have given up. Linearity keeps hard games like this replayable.

Linearity and Replayability

At the time, the most common reason given for the decline of adventure games in the late 90's is their linearity. Adventure games had strong, coherent narratives that play out like movies, and this kept the games from being replayable. Players wanted more agency in their games; the future of video games was more choice, more non-linearity.

But if nonlinearity equals replayability, then why are completely linear games like Contra so endlessly replayable? One could argue that I'm not really replaying Contra III, since I haven't beaten it yet. But I have beaten Castlevania, and I keep coming back to it. It provides challenging, hypnotizing gameplay with no real time commitment. That seems to me to be the definition of replayable.


As far as adventure games go, I've replayed the Gabriel Knight series more than any other games I can think of. I've played the third game at least five times. (In fact, they're more fun when you don't get stuck on every puzzle.) It's like rewatching a favorite movie.

Some games are not very replayable to me, even when there are choices involved. Silent Hill 2 is probably my favorite console game, and there was a time when I wanted to see all six endings, which requires you to play the game six times. To this day, I've only seen two of them, for a number of reasons. Firstly, the game gets less scary when you replay it; less to do with linearity than with the horror genre itself. Secondly, the game is unique in that the endings reflect how you've chosen to play the game (do you use first aid often, how close do you stick to Maria?) and so it's tricky to force the game to a specific ending.




The third reason is more relevant to this discussion, since I generally feel this way about games with choice. To me, my first ending will always be my ending. Even though I did not consciously choose it, it is how I would've wanted the game to end (it is arguably the 'best' ending for the character). Two of my friends got a different ending (a more tragic one) that they are both happy with. When I force the game to end a different way, it feels like I'm making that choice...well, not really a choice. So I choose not to replay it, and savor my version of the story.

So in certain ways, linear games are more replayable and nonlinear games are less so. There's more to be said here, so...next time.

Screenshots from MobyGames, as if it wasn't obvious.